How many studies will it take before we admit that a formula on paper is no substitute for measuring what’s actually coming out of a landfill?. For decades, landfill methane regulation and policy has been built on estimates. The U.S. EPA uses simplistic models to predict how much methane landfills produce. Based on those assumptions, municipal solid waste landfills emitted approximately 3.7 million metric tons of methane in 2022, making them the third-largest source of methane emissions in the United States. But an estimate is only as good as the assumptions behind it, and the evidence keeps showing that those assumptions miss the mark. A study published in Science found super-emitters (very large clouds of methane) at 52 percent of surveyed landfills. Now a study out of Canada adds to the case.
Models Don’t Match Reality
Researchers at FluxLab at St. Francis Xavier University, with coauthors from Environment and Climate Change Canada (the federal agency responsible for Canada's greenhouse gas inventory) actually measured what was actually escaping into the atmosphere from landfills, and found challenges with what models show. Using direct measurements at 42 Canadian landfills, researchers found major discrepancies between actual methane measurements and Canada's inventory model. At many landfills in colder, drier regions, measured emissions came in lower than the model predicted. At warmer, wetter landfills, they came in higher.
So the researchers didn’t conclude that inventories are always too high or always too low. They reached a more important conclusion: methane inventories should be grounded in real-world measurements, not assumptions alone.
They also found something regulators can act on right away. On site, the biggest methane sources were consistently active working faces (where fresh trash is being dumped), newly placed waste, leachate wells, manholes, and construction activities. Incredibly, during some construction work, methane levels went past the top of what the researchers’ instruments could measure.
The tools exist, we know where the methane is, now the rules need to catch up.
There’s no shortage of proven, cost-effective technologies that are already working at landfills across North America. In fact, we recently spent an hour hearing from some of the leaders in this fast-growing tech sector at our landfill technology showcase! The challenge isn’t lack of solutions - it’s lack of widespread implementation. In the U.S., federal regulations still rely heavily on convoluted formulas and outdated monitoring methods that let huge amounts of methane escape into the atmosphere unaccounted for.
Fortunately, states are moving beyond outdated approaches. California's new landfill methane regulations require monitoring across the entire landfill, including active working faces that were largely overlooked under previous rules. Under the updated rules, landfill operators must use advanced monitoring technologies including drones and other remote sensing tools to investigate large methane emissions and identify leaks that conventional walking surveys can miss. Colorado has also expanded the use of advanced monitoring technologies and strengthened requirements for finding and fixing methane emissions. Other states, including New York, Michigan and Illinois, are poised to follow as they weigh new standards for landfill operations.
We know where the methane is coming from, we have the tools - now the rules need to catch up.